From: Daniel Golle Subject: [PATCH] JavaScriptCore: disable useWasmFastMemory on RISCV64 Base RISC-V doesn't require stores that fault to be atomic w.r.t. the fault: hardware may commit some in-bound bytes of a 2/4/8-byte store before raising the page-fault exception when the access straddles a page boundary into PROT_NONE memory. SiFive U74 (StarFive JH7110) does this. JSC's "fast memory" mode (useWasmFastMemory=true) relies on the SIGBUS/SIGSEGV handler to convert OOB accesses into wasm traps without an explicit bounds check. The handler observes the fault and traps the wasm correctly, but the in-bounds bytes already corrupted by the partial commit remain in memory. Subsequent reads see wrong data. Reproducer: spec-tests/memory_trap.wast.js #295. Test 51 of the same file does i32.store at offset 65535 (1 in-bound byte, 3 OOB bytes); expected to trap. The trap fires but byte 65535 gets clobbered to 0 before the fault. Later test #295 reads i64 at offset 65528 (covering bytes 65528..65535) and finds 0x0067666564636261 instead of 0x6867666564636261 -- the assertion against the i64 const trips the wasm "unreachable" guard. Force-disable useWasmFastMemory on RISCV64; bounds checking falls back to the explicit BoundsChecking mode in emitCheckAndPreparePointer, which checks the access upper bound against the memory size before issuing any load/store. Signed-off-by: Daniel Golle --- --- a/Source/JavaScriptCore/runtime/Options.cpp +++ b/Source/JavaScriptCore/runtime/Options.cpp @@ -804,6 +804,21 @@ void Options::notifyOptionsChanged() #endif #endif +#if CPU(RISCV64) + // The base RISC-V ISA permits a faulting store to commit some of its + // bytes before raising the exception (single-copy atomicity is only + // guaranteed for naturally-aligned accesses up to XLEN, not for a + // store that straddles a page boundary into PROT_NONE). On hardware + // that does this (e.g. SiFive U74 in JH7110), JSC's signal-based + // bounds check sees the page fault but the in-bounds bytes have + // already been corrupted -- subsequent reads return wrong values. + // Force explicit bounds checking instead. Reproducer: + // spec-tests/memory_trap.wast.js #295 (i32.store at 65535 partially + // overwrites byte 65535 before trapping, then i64.load at 65528 + // sees the corrupted high byte). + Options::useWasmFastMemory() = false; +#endif + #if !CPU(ARM64) Options::useRandomizingExecutableIslandAllocation() = false; #endif